The Role of Job Task Degradation in Shaping Return Intentions: Evidence from Ukrainian War Refugees in Poland

6 March 2025
abstract:

This paper studies the relationship between occupational experiences and return intentions of Ukrainian war refugees in Poland, following Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Using country-wide, online surveys conducted in 2022 and 2023, we show that refugees’ high employment rate co-exists with widespread occupational downgrading and job task degradation. Refugees transitioning to lower-skilled jobs after arriving in Poland faced stark increases in routine task intensity (RTI), often equivalent to shifts from managerial to clerical roles. Even those retaining their occupational categories experienced heightened RTI, signalling underutilisation of skills. We find a significant relationship between such task degradation and return intentions: refugees subjected to greater task degradation were more likely to plan to return to Ukraine by 2023, particularly those who initially, in 2022, intend to stay in Poland. This relationship persists even after accounting for earnings and occupational downgrading. These findings underscore the role of job content in shaping migration decisions and highlight implications for host countries’ labour market policies and refugee integration strategies.

keywords: migration, return intentions, occupational downgrading, task content of jobs
JEL codes: 
publication year: 2025
language: english
Publications category: 
publishing series: IBS Working Paper
publication number: 01/2025
ISSN: 2451-4373
Additional information:

We thank the participants of the “Return and Integration Prospects of Ukrainian Refugees” workshop in Nuremberg for their helpful comments. The paper uses data collected in a survey financially supported by the International Organization for Migration. Usual disclaimers apply. All errors are ours.

authors:

Institute for Structural Research (IBS), IZA, RWI

Institute for Structural Research (IBS)

Institute for Structural Research (IBS)

We value your privacy
Cookie settings
Some cookies are necessary for the proper operation of our site. We also encourage you to agree to the use of analytical tool cookies. They allow us to continuously improve the site. You can find more information in the Privacy Policy. More.
Customize Reject all Accept all
Cookie settings
Customize settings
"Necessary" cookies are required for the operation of the site. Consent to the other categories, will help us improve the operation of the site. Third-party companies, such as: Google, also store cookies. For more information: data use and privacy. Cookies set by Google for logged in users.
Necessary cookies are required for the proper operation of the site.
Store the data of analytical tools such as: Google Analytics.
They store data related to the ad function.
Allows user data related to advertisements to be sent to Google

There is no cookies.

Allows personalized ads to be displayed

There is no cookies.

Save settings Accept all
Cookie settings
Skip to content